Put Options Versus Stock Ownership

Traditional buy and hold strategies have long been proven effective over the long term, especially when investors select quality companies. However, buy and hold is actually the least efficient investing method when it comes to generating returns. Although we have a bias for options, it is important that investors educate themselves on alternatives to just buy and hold because beating the market while driving on the same highway as everyone else is nearly impossible.

Hedge fund managers and professional traders often employ the use options over owning stock. Stock ownership requires significant capital and produces lower returns versus selling options. The advantage of using options is the ability to profit even when the stock falls; stock ownership has no room for error.

Take for example Google shares, now known as Alphabet. Priced at $827, these shares are most likely out of reach for the average investor looking to fulfill a board lot. This would require almost $83,000 just to avoid interest. However, selling a put option just out of the money (820 strike) would require only $17,200 cash. The difference in capital requirements is staggering and can actually limit the demand for companies. The ability for younger or financially strapped investors to buy and hold is often burdening and not possible.

If we take the 2018 LEAPs, you can sell the $820 puts and earn $67 a share. This is immediately paid to you. Regardless of what the shares are valued in a year from now, you keep the $67. This represents a return of almost 39% for the year. To match the same return in percent for a stock owner, the shares would need to climb to $1,150. To match the return in dollar value, shares would need to climb to $894. Now, selling a put does have its own risks as well. If the shares fall, you would be obligated to buy the stock at $820 or close the option. However, if the shares are worth more than $753, you would still be left with a profit. This advantage only lies with an option trader.

If the stock owner had purchased the shares in 2017 and held them for one year only to see the shares fall to $770, the stock owner would see a paper loss of $57 a share or $5700 per board lot. We however, have seen a profit of $17 a share or $1700. The cost to close the option on expiration date would be $50 but we received $67. This is an example of more efficient investing. Since Alphabet shares do not currently pay a dividend, there is no added benefit on owning the shares with the exception that the stock could be worth more than $1,150 in a year (let's see how it plays out), but this is worthwhile trade-off for option traders. It is very rare for a stock to return 40% a year every year and in the long term, the reality is that the option trader will be better off than an investor with a buy and hold strategy.